|
Real-Time Locating System Cost-Performance Comparative Analysis
|
|
|
AVANTE
RTLS
|
WiFi
(2.45 GHz)
|
UWB
(6-8 GHz)
|
Time-Lapsed Method
(2.45 GHz)
|
|
Technology
|
q Received signal strength with dynamic zoning
q Not dependent on line-of-sight
|
q Received signal strength and…
|
q Time Difference of Arrival
q Need line-of-sight for accuracy
|
q Time Difference of Arrival
q Need line-of-sight for accuracy
|
|
Visibility in Time
|
§ 1 Second
|
§ >10 Seconds
|
§ >5 Seconds
|
§ >10 Seconds
|
|
Visibility in Environment
|
§ Same for Indoor and Outdoor
§ Independent on humidity
|
§ Same for Indoor and Outdoor
§ Some dependent on humidity
|
§ Mostly Outdoor
§ Indoor need line-of-sight
§ May be difficult on rainy day
|
§ Mostly Outdoor
§ Indoor need line-of-sight
§ Some dependent on humidity
|
|
Accuracy for Assets
|
o 3-6 ft
|
o 10-20 ft
o Some system claims 4-10 ft
|
o 0.5-10 ft
o Depends on line-of-sight
|
o 5-10 ft
o Depends on line-of-sight
|
|
Accuracy for Personnel
|
v Proven accuracy for personnel badge
|
v Difficult when near human
|
v Difficult when near human
|
v Difficult when near human
|
|
1,000 Assets System (Price may vary depending on different requirements)
|
|
Cost of Tags
(1,000 Assets)
|
· $30 ea.
· $30,000
|
· $50 ea.
· $50,000
|
· $50 ea.
· $50,000
|
· $50 ea.
· $50,000
|
|
Cost of Reader Network
(For 100,000 sq. ft space)
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 4 readers minimum
Ø $8000
|
Ø $30 ea.
Ø Use existing WiFi access points
Ø $0
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 4 readers minimum
Ø $8000
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 4 readers minimum
Ø $8000
|
|
Total System Hardware Costs
|
§ $38,000
|
§ $50,000
|
§ $58,000
|
§ $58,000
|
|
10,000 Assets System (Price may vary depending on different requirements)
|
|
Cost of Tags
(10,000 Assets)
|
· $20 ea.
· $200,000
|
· $40 ea.
· $400,000
|
· $40 ea.
· $400,000
|
· $40 ea.
· $400,000
|
|
Cost of Reader Network
(For 100,000 sq. ft space)
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 10 readers minimum
Ø $20,000
|
Ø $30 ea.
Ø Use existing WiFi access points
Ø $0
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 10 readers minimum
Ø $20,000
|
Ø $2000 ea.
Ø 10 readers minimum
Ø $20,000
|
|
Total System Hardware Costs
|
§ $220,000
|
§ $400,000
|
§ $420,000
|
§ $420,000
|
|
Other Comments:
§ Implementation labor costs should be similar based on same needs for “calibration”
§ Software costs should be comparable and is not included in this comparison
§ Contrary to most assertions, system costs are directly proportional to the costs of tags
|